diff --git a/Config.cs b/Config.cs
index 4b585b2..6370206 100644
--- a/Config.cs
+++ b/Config.cs
@@ -19,6 +19,7 @@ namespace CustomCosmeticLoader
 		public const string PROPERTY_IN_MAIN_MENU = "inMainMenu";
 		public const string PROPERTY_IN_COSMETIC_MENU = "inCosmeticMenu";
 		public const string PROPERTY_IN_ALL_REPLAYS = "inAllReplays";
+		public const string PROPERTY_OVERRIDE_REPLAY_COSMETICS = "overrideReplayCosmetics";
 		public const string PROPERTY_OTHER_PLAYERS = "otherPlayers";
 
 		public static bool enabled = true;
@@ -27,6 +28,7 @@ namespace CustomCosmeticLoader
 		public static bool inMainMenu = true;
 		public static bool inCosmeticMenu = false;
 		public static bool inAllReplays = false;
+		public static bool overrideReplayCosmetics = false;
 		public static Dictionary<string, string> otherPlayers = new Dictionary<string, string>();
 
 		public static Dictionary<string, Texture2D> skins = new Dictionary<string, Texture2D>();
@@ -83,6 +85,9 @@ namespace CustomCosmeticLoader
 			if (data[PROPERTY_IN_ALL_REPLAYS] != null)
 				inAllReplays = data[PROPERTY_IN_ALL_REPLAYS].AsBool;
 
+			if (data[PROPERTY_OVERRIDE_REPLAY_COSMETICS] != null)
+				overrideReplayCosmetics = data[PROPERTY_OVERRIDE_REPLAY_COSMETICS].AsBool;
+
 			if (data[PROPERTY_OTHER_PLAYERS] != null)
 			{
 				JSONClass otherPlayersData = data[PROPERTY_OTHER_PLAYERS].AsObject;
@@ -116,6 +121,7 @@ namespace CustomCosmeticLoader
 				{ PROPERTY_IN_MAIN_MENU, inMainMenu ? "true" : "false" },
 				{ PROPERTY_IN_COSMETIC_MENU, inCosmeticMenu ? "true" : "false" },
 				{ PROPERTY_IN_ALL_REPLAYS, inAllReplays ? "true" : "false" },
+				{ PROPERTY_OVERRIDE_REPLAY_COSMETICS, overrideReplayCosmetics ? "true" : "false" },
 			};
 
 			JSONNode otherPlayersData = new JSONClass();
diff --git a/ConsoleCommands.cs b/ConsoleCommands.cs
index ac9d1ed..ea16dfc 100644
--- a/ConsoleCommands.cs
+++ b/ConsoleCommands.cs
@@ -140,5 +140,19 @@ namespace CustomCosmeticLoader
 
 			return "Custom skins in all replays " + (Config.inAllReplays ? "enabled" : "disabled");
 		}
+
+		[ConsoleCommand(description = "Enable/disable overriding a replay's cosmetics with your cosmetics", paramsDescription = "[true/false]", hidden = true)]
+		public static string cclOverrideReplayCosmetics(params string[] args)
+		{
+			if (args.Length == 0)
+				return "overrideReplayCosmetics: " + (Config.overrideReplayCosmetics ? "true" : "false"); ;
+
+			if (args.Length != 1 || (args[0] != "true" && args[0] != "false"))
+				return "Requires a true or false argument";
+
+			Config.overrideReplayCosmetics = args[0] == "true";
+
+			return "Overriding cosmetics in all replays " + (Config.overrideReplayCosmetics ? "enabled" : "disabled");
+		}
 	}
 }
diff --git a/Patches/MarbleControllerPatches.cs b/Patches/MarbleControllerPatches.cs
index f6c872b..36e4ba2 100644
--- a/Patches/MarbleControllerPatches.cs
+++ b/Patches/MarbleControllerPatches.cs
@@ -35,11 +35,28 @@ namespace CustomCosmeticLoader.Patches
 
 	/*
 	 * Hijack the cosmetic of the marble when watching Replays. This doesn't apply the custom texture, just swaps out
-	 * the marble with the designated marble to hijack.
+	 * the marble with the designated marble to hijack. If overrideReplayCosmetics is enabled, we swap out all cosmetics
+	 * to match our current configuration to view the replay that way.
 	 */
 	[HarmonyPatch(typeof(MarbleController), nameof(MarbleController.ApplyCosmetics))]
 	internal class MarbleControllerApplyCosmeticsPatch
 	{
+		static void Prefix(ref ReplayCosmetics cosmetics)
+		{
+			// Actually, we can let this one run even if the custom skins are disabled
+			//if (!Config.enabled)
+			//	return;
+
+			if (!Config.overrideReplayCosmetics)
+				return;
+
+			cosmetics.Skin = CosmeticManager.MySkin.Id;
+			cosmetics.Trail = CosmeticManager.MyTrail.Id;
+			cosmetics.Respawn = CosmeticManager.MyRespawn.Id;
+			cosmetics.Hat = CosmeticManager.MyHat.Id;
+			cosmetics.Blast = CosmeticManager.MyBlast.Id;
+		}
+
 		static void Postfix(MarbleController __instance, ReplayCosmetics cosmetics)
 		{
 			if (!Config.enabled)